What changes when context emerges from records?
RGM / Relational Space investigates deriving contexts from record memberships rather than assigning classes in advance. H1a is the narrow experiment line testing their value for evidence retrieval. Design, calibration records and open gates are collected here.
The research question
Consider two systems with the same records, encoder and retrieval budget. One uses fixed contexts; the other derives them from record distribution. Does the latter find evidence for a query more effectively? That is H1a’s primary question, not a test of every claim in the broader architecture.
- Separate sources from organization.
- Persistent epistemic content stays in records. Contexts, topology and representations can be rebuilt; they do not become new sources of knowledge.
- Use is not evidence.
- Similarity, centrality, repetition and usage are distinct quantities. Query history must not change canonical knowledge or topology.
- A minimal test, a bounded result.
- H1a tests anonymous membership and derived context for retrieval. Role ports, paths, facets, online organization and conceptuality need separate hypotheses.
Minimal model and comparisons
From source records to evidence retrieval
Preserve records and provenance
One message is the record unit; session, order and source provenance remain distinct. Evaluation questions are not inserted into record content.
Construct context memberships
Fixed schemas or offline-derived structures assign records to contexts. Hidden class information derived from queries is not used.
Retrieve under the same budget
Use the shared first stage and bounded expansion. A record does not gain extra votes merely by appearing in more active contexts.
Compare arms and controls
The primary contrast is E_off − F. Null models, neighbourhood, stability and interpretability test different explanations; one score is insufficient.
| Arm | Role | Distinction |
|---|---|---|
| B0 | Shared first stage | Baseline without expansion. |
| N | Neighbour expansion | Does any gain come merely from adding nearest neighbours? |
| F | Fixed-schema context | The fixed-structure side of the primary contrast. |
| R_F | Null model of F | Degree-preserving rewiring of F memberships. |
| E_off | Offline-derived context | The derived-structure side of the primary hypothesis. |
| R_E | Null model of E_off | Degree-preserving rewiring of the derived structure. |
| E_on | Online-derived context | A separate secondary test of incremental organization. |
What is measured?
- Primary metric
- EvidenceRecall@10; LongMemEval-S is confirmatory, LoCoMo is directional replication.
- Control gates
- Null and neighbourhood comparisons, stability and interpretability are considered together.
- Cost and scope
- Report candidate budgets, latency and exclusion rules. Partially resolved gold evidence is not rescued by shrinking the gold set.
H1a experiment record
This is a read-only review dated 23 October 2026 of local design documents and calibration reports only. No new experiment was run. Raw conversations, decision questions and decision-split retrieval outcomes were not opened.
From calibration to the decision gate
A · shared retrieval settings
Encoder and BM25 selection remain in the calibration report. This is not an H1a hypothesis result.
B · retrieval budget
n, m and C choices are fixed in a separate report; decision metrics do not drive new selection.
C · context configuration
Offline and online context selection records remain preserved. They do not independently establish superiority.
v0.4 · null mixing calibration
The required α could not be selected. Report checks passed, but the calibration condition did not; the confirmatory experiment was not reached.
v0.5 · method amendment
Changes only null-model mixing adequacy. The hypothesis, datasets and primary success criteria are unchanged.
Reference machine and Lock 2
The inspected gate report has all_checks_pass=false and retrieval_used=false. It does not show that required transfer and locking gates passed on the new reference machine.
Passing technical report checks does not mean passing a research gate. The v0.4 closure neither supports nor falsifies H1a: the decision partition was not reached.
Reading the research
Method notes
These notes concern publishing an unsuccessful experiment and reproducing the separate ERM prototype. They are not RGM experiment reports or evidence of an H1a outcome.
How do we publish an unsuccessful experiment?
From an ADL experiment that missed its target to Evidrel’s decision traces: keeping expectations, observations and later explanations distinct.
A reproduction record in ERM
Inputs, file identities, evidence and the limits of human evaluation through ERM v0.12’s dated validation records.
Sources and H1a guide
H1a source and reading guide
An offline-readable Markdown summary in this page’s language, including SHA-256 source identities. It contains no questions, conversations, embeddings or decision outputs.
Download guide · MarkdownPrimary source register
These documents were inspected in the local research source. Public repository access could not be verified, so no guessed original-file links are supplied. The downloadable guide contains scope, citations and file hashes, not the original package or raw data.
Constitution
Source, representation, usage and the minimal/broader architecture distinction.
00-anayasa-v0.4.mdReference architecture
Records, memberships, contexts, derived views and retrieval responsibilities.
01-referans-mimari-v0.4.mdResearch program
Hypothesis scopes and separate tests beyond H1a.
02-arastirma-programi-v0.4.mdLiterature and decision record
Related work and limits of research positioning.
03-literatur-karar-kaydi-v0.4.mdH1a preregistration
Primary contrast, arms, data separation, metrics and locking rules.
H1a-on-kayit-v0.4.mdH1a method amendment
Pre-decision mixing-adequacy change and transfer conditions.
H1a-on-kayit-v0.5-degisiklik.mdA–C calibration reports
Separate selection records for shared retrieval, budgets and context settings.
stage_a_report.json / stage_b_report.json / stage_c_report.jsonNull α calibration report
mixing_plateau_not_reached; α was not selected and no decision result followed.
alpha_report.jsonReference-machine gate
Failed technical gate and a record that retrieval metrics were not used.
refmachine_gate_report.jsonResearch decision log
Closure, amendment, reference-machine deviation and Lock 2 gates.
DECISIONS.mdDataset and encoder sources
Existing project text and dated sources
The original editable RGM entry is preserved below. The portal provides full accounts in five languages; earlier summary translations remain part of the historical record.
Can derived context improve retrieval?
Can contexts derived from record memberships improve evidence retrieval over fixed contexts? This RGM entry covers the Relational Space / ERM H1a experiment line. The ERM prototype combining patterns and statements has a separate entry.
A minimal question within a broader architecture
H1a is designed to test the minimal model: source records, anonymous memberships and derived contexts. Role ports, paths, facets and the broader architecture depend on separate hypotheses. A minimal retrieval result cannot validate them all.
The primary comparison is offline-derived context against fixed-schema context. Null-model and neighbourhood controls, stability, interpretability and cost also matter. One retrieval score does not fulfil the whole research claim.
Calibration and decision are separate
The reviewed v0.5 amendment changes the null-model mixing adequacy rule, not the primary hypothesis or datasets. Calibration reports remain distinct from decision-run outcomes.
It also records a cross-platform reproducibility risk: some selected E_off structures on Mac differed from the reference Linux structures. A reference-machine gate is therefore a substantive experimental control.
The scope of this entry
This page describes design and calibration, not a final H1a superiority result. Deriving contexts from anonymous memberships alone does not establish learned meaning or completion of the broader architecture.
Source note
Sources reviewed on 14 October 2026: Relational Space constitution and reference architecture v0.4, H1a preregistration v0.4, v0.5 amendment and decision record. No experiment was run, and no raw conversations or decision-split inputs were opened for this entry.
Status and open limits
Prepared on 23 October 2026 for RGM / Relational Space H1a, using the v0.4 calibration closure and the v0.5 amendment draft dated 14 October. The inspected records do not establish a final E_off − F superiority result or a completed Lock 2.
Calibration and decision partitions must remain separate. Carrying A–C from the old Linux reference to a new machine is a recorded deviation and reproduction obligation. Documenting an amendment does not establish completion of a signed amendment lock or a new confirmatory run. Retrieval value from derived contexts is not general meaning learning or completion of the broader architecture.
Calibration ≠ final decision. Technical checks ≠ hypothesis support. Derived context ≠ learned general meaning.
ERM — relational memory prototype
ERM v0.12 evaluates patterns and declarations within the same event frame. It is not this H1a retrieval mechanism, and neither line’s results establish the other’s success.